Part 1: Summary
Cooperative learning, more commonly known as grouping, has been integrated into education prior to the twentieth century. At first many instructors grouped children according to ability, but the trend since the early 1980’s has shown evidence from research that heterogeneous groups are more beneficial. Although research shows that homogeneous grouping is better than none, researchers lean toward heterogeneous as the better choice of the two, considering the percentile gains of the lowest group being in the negatives(-23), medium benefiting the most at 19% and highest ability students only at 3%. Marzano discusses five elements that define cooperative learning in regard to beneficial effects. When implemented correctly students can gain the following; positive interdependence, face-to-face promotive interaction, individual and group accountability, interpersonal and small group skills and group processing skills. When considering this technique teachers need to remember that when organizing groups, it is better for students to be grouped on ability only occasionally, keep groups to a small size of three to four and apply it consistently and systematically, not overusing the technique.
Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class
A connection to this reading was evident in a text I am reading for a project in another class, What Every Teacher Should Know About Classroom Management and Discipline by Donna Tileston. Marzano discusses managing group sizes and making changes as necessary to maximize the application of cooperative group benefits in the learning environment. Tileston refers to schools and/or classrooms who utilize cooperative learning and describes the chances given to participate as “building on a natural need to collaborate” due to our brains being “social organisms.” She also mentions three learning settings which include, competitive, individualistic and cooperative. Cooperative learning offers a chance to help each other be successful and gives the idea that “we are in this together”, which promotes positive interdependence along with naturally incorporating social skills.
Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
During my observation time, I have witnessed cooperative learning quite frequently due to the fact that the class I am in lends to “group work.” I am in a foods lab in which there are six kitchens that hold up to four students per group. Days that do not include a lab, students are in different seats and at times engage in cooperative learning activities for class work. At the beginning of the school year, students were given the choice of who their lab group would be and the teacher assigned seats for days in which lab was not scheduled. The assigning of seats during regular class time helped in classroom management in that the students were not necessarily next to their friends, which could be distracting at times. I felt that providing them with the choice of lab groups was a good idea because of the nature of working in a kitchen with others lends to development of positive relationships and build a sense of trust within groups. Although, recently the teacher chose to mix groups up randomly by selecting names out of a bowl for a “meal” lab that requires more planning and two days to complete. She felt that the regular lab groups needed switching for the meal lab to assess their ability to work with others while completing a more complicated lab. One class was very upset at first and argued that they were accustomed to their groups and worked well together within them, but during planning time was able to work well together and complete necessary tasks for planning the lab. The teacher felt that many students were too comfortable in their own groups, which in some cases resulted in an increase of mistakes, noise level and lack of motivation for completing tasks. She wanted to see how they would respond to working with different people in regard to work ethic and listening skills. We as humans get to a comfortable level and some resist change because of various reasons. These students seemed to lack confidence in some fellow classmates, but ultimately responded well in completing the first few tasks assigned in the project. This type of grouping seemed to elicit a negative response at first, but has proven to be beneficial to the majority of the students thus far.
There is lots of information here and a great model demonstrated by your mentor/supervisor. By splitting up the group, she demonstrated both authority and the ability to allow students to prove their knowledge in the kitchen. You are right in that student become complacent when they don’t change duties or groups, and this can be very disastrous. Switching groups always promotes angst about fellow group member’s performance. So this becomes a lesson on tolerance, trust, and accommodation. Great display of classroom management!
ReplyDeleteAs I was reading the beginning of your application section I was thinking to myself that a whole year seems like a long time to be in the same lab group. I think it was a good strategy to mix up the lab groups for at least one activity. It may have benefited a group who was not working well together or needed a little break from each other.
ReplyDelete